“Age Ratings” Argument Essay
Lulu Tenney 807
Has someone ever
told you that you can’t do something that you love? That’s what adults are
doing by putting age ratings on books. Adults are putting age ratings on Young Adult books, but they
don’t realize by doing this, that they are taking away teenagers’ freedom,
responsibility, and independence. I think that there shouldn’t be age ratings
for books because students have the maturity to read what they wish, and their
rights as human beings shouldn’t be taken away from them.
Young Adult, or “YA” books save teens
because it shows them that they aren’t alone, and that other people, or
characters relate with what they are going through. There was a popular hashtag
on twitter called #YAsaves, where teens would tweet heartfelt responses to how
YA saved them in their darkest moments. Teen blogger Emma says, “good
literature rips open all the private parts of us- the parts that people have
deemed too dark, inappropriate, grotesque, or abnormal for teens to be feeling-
and then they stitch it back together again before we can realize that they
aren’t talking about us.” This shows that these books are portraying what these
teens are going through so well, that teens feel like the books are talking
about their own situations. In the article, “Has young adult fiction become too
dark?” by Mary Elizabeth Williams, she says, “That’s why it matters; why, in
the name of protecting teens, we can’t shut them off from the outlet of
experiencing difficult events and feelings in the relative safety and profound
comfort of literature. Darkness isn’t the enemy. But ignorance always is.” YA is a comfort for these young readers
and without them, they would be completely shut off from the sad truths of
life. Adults have the right to read whatever books or movies they want, so why don’t
young adults?
Teens read YA
because teens need to know about what happens in the real world, and YA teaches
them that. Teens don’t mind the darkness of the world or of YA books because as
author of dark YA literature, Patrick Ness, says, “teens are dark.” “All you
have to do is read what teens write themselves, and I’ve judged competitions
for teens writing and its darkness is beyond anything I could come up with.”
Teens already know about these dark truths of life, and they need to know about
it in the real world and when they are grown up, so why not let YA fiction,
something that they enjoy, teach them about it?
On the other hand,
parents think that teens shouldn’t have access to YA books, but teens actually
have access to many worse things. Patrick Ness says, “teens look at the internet,
they look at the news, they look at violent movies on the internet, and they
look at pornography on the internet. So if children’s literature is not
addressing that, if it’s addressing the world as it should be rather than as it
is, then why would a teen read you?” Teens also see and hear about sad things
that happen in their day-to-day lives, so hearing about them in books isn’t any
different. Teens are smart- they can find something that they want easily, and
Patrick Ness says, “if it’s got an 18 certificate for adults, then younger
children will look it out when their parents are not around… Children are great
self-censors. They know what they can read and they know what they want to
read, and if you don’t give it to them, they’ll find it somehow.” They are
responsible enough to know for themselves which books are too mature for them,
so if teens want a book, why can’t they get it?
Although this is a
very controversial topic with good points on each side, I strongly believe that
adults should give children the responsibility that they deserve and that there
shouldn’t be age ratings for books. I think that adults should stop trying to
promote age ratings, and start with age ratings for internet content, because
right now I think that that is the bigger issue.